The pain lozenge

Chronic Inflammation in the Body | Treatment

There is no pain without inflammation.

The inflammation leading to pain may be obvious - like when a bee sting turns red, warm, swollen and painful. There is obvious tissue damage and immediate pain.

But inflammation and tissue damage can also be hidden - as seems more often the case. Inflammation is hidden when it exists only at the cellular level. Then it's microscopic - and hard to detect even with lab tests.

But just like inflammation you can see, microscopic inflammation leads to tissue damage and pain, if not immediately then eventually.

Effective treatment of pain therefore requires effective treatment of inflammation - including microscopic inflammation. There's no other way to stop the ongoing tissue damage and certainly no better way to stop the pain.



Chronic Inflammation Notes

Demyelination: a vicious cycle in multiple sclerosis

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is generally regarded as an autoimmune disease – one in which the immune system mistakenly attacks a part of the body – in this case the covering of neurons in the central nervous system.

Without their insulating cover, the nerves do not function properly. MS can result in widely varying symptoms depending on which nerves are ‘attacked.’

The study abstract summarized below does not directly reference multiple sclerosis. But it does suggest one possible mechanism by which an initially small lesion could progress, and how the disease might be self-sustaining.

Damage to the nerve covering – the myelin sheath – releases sulfatide. Sulfatide then triggers inflammation via activation of NF-kB. The inflammation leads to further damage to the nerve sheath, further release of sulfatide, more NF-kB activation, more inflammation, etc.

It seems likely that those without multiple sclerosis suffer occasional damage to a myelin sheath, but that such damage does not become progressively worse, despite the release of sulfatide.

It may be that the immune system of those who do not suffer with multiple sclerosis is better able to shut down inflammation and prevent the vicious cycle from developing.

Perhaps by providing supplemental NF-kB inhibitors we could prevent self-perpetuating inflammation in multiple sclerosis, or at least reduce the severity of that inflammation – thereby lessening damage and speeding the onset of remission.

NF-kappaB: Autoimmunity master switch

The abstract below does not say much. It merely suggests the central importance of NF-kB and then provides a very partial list of the autoimmune conditions for which NF-kB activation is central.

However, the full text article is a good overview, and is available free online.

Lupus, Asthma & NF-kappaB

Dendritic cells stimulate the immune system by presenting antigens (foreign particles) to other immune cells and by causing the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines. It is believed that dendritic cells may play an important role in autoimmune disease.

The serum from patients with lupus causes monocytes to transform into dendritic cells and is associated with increased NF-kB activation.

The serum from patients with asthma also causes monocytes to transform into dendritic cells and is associated with increased NF-kB activation.

Inhibition of NF-kB contributes to T cell tolerance – by which is meant tolerance to self. When “tolerant” T cells do not attack self. T cell intolerance may lead to autoimmune disease.

Auto-antibodies in lupus stimulate NF-kappaB

High levels of different auto-antibodies are commonly found in lupus, as well as other autoimmune disease. One type of auto-antibody is directed against double-stranded DNA.

In the study below, researchers looked at four variations of that auto-antibody and found that all four resulted in an increase in TNF – a pro-inflammatory mediator.

Two of the four variants were found to activate NF-kB, suggesting that at least some of the damage caused by these auto-antibodies results from their ability to turn on NF-kB.

This is a very significant finding, and furthers the theory that inhibition of NF-kB might be of value in lupus, as well as other autoimmune disease.

IL-17, NF-kappaB & Lupus

Studies have suggested involvement of interleukin 17 (IL-17) in autoimmune diseases, although its effect on B cell biology has not been clearly established.

Here we demonstrate that IL-17 alone or in combination with B cell-activating factor controlled the survival and proliferation of human B cells and their differentiation into immunoglobulin-secreting cells. This effect was mediated mainly through the nuclear factor-kappaB-regulated transcription factor Twist-1.

Genetic analysis suggests critical role of NF-kappaB in MS relapse

NF-kB plays a central role in triggering relapse in multiple sclerosis.

The reason for relapse in multiple sclerosis is unknown.

The researchers identified 43 genes that were differently expressed during acute relapse vs. complete remission. After analyzing these differences they conclude that NF-kB plays a central role in triggering relapse.

This is consistent with the theory that a pro-inflammatory state (common to most individuals in the Western world) leads to chronic over activation of NF-kB. In combination with genetic vulnerability, autoimmune disease can manifest.

By restoring the proper balance between inflammation inhibitors and inflammation promoters, this pro-inflammatory state might be relieved. NF-kB might then no longer be chronically over-activated, which might lessen the chance of remission in multiple sclerosis.

NF-kappaB inhibition as a therapeutic objective in multiple sclerosis treatment

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a chronic inflammatory, demyelinating and neurodegenerative disorder of the central nervous system (CNS) of unknown cause.

We do not know its cause, and we have yet to identify an ideal treatment, but what we do know is:

* NF-kB is a central player in the activation of T cells, B cells, dendritic cells, macrophages, and CNS resident glia – all of which are believed to be important in MS disease progression.

* NF-kB is induced by a large number of extracellular signals and its activation results in both increased production of pro-inflammatory cytokines and increased production of antibody by B cells.

* IL-17 is probably a key player in MS as well as other autoimmune conditions, and it is a potent activator of NF-kB.

* Activation of NF-kB in microglial cells and astrocytes of MS patients is known to result in the production of proinflammatory cytokines and potentially neurotoxic mediators.

* Some drugs currently used in the treatment of MS, such as beta-interferon, are thought to act primarily via inhibition of NF-kB.

* Curcumin, a major constituent of turmeric, has recently been shown to be effective in the treatment of a wide variety of diseases, including cancer, infection, and autoimmune disease. Curcumin inhibits production of IL-17, and appears to act by inhibiting NF-kB.

* Many MS patients have a reduced frequency of relapses during pregnancy, due at least in part to altered levels of estrogens. Studies suggest that estrogens inhibit NF-kB, leading to reduced T cell transmigration into the CNS in MS patients and reduced cytokine production.

Taken together, these findings suggest the potential therapeutic benefit of NF-kB inhibition.

Fibromyalgia ulcerative colitis and Crohn’s disease linked

Fibromyalgia and Inflammatory Bowel Disease

Common musculoskeletal conditions among those with inflammatory bowel disease – arthritis and fibromyalgia.

Three observations suggest that we might be looking at a single underlying mechanism of disease.

An effective NF-kappaB inhibitor might be a great pain drug

An NF-kB inhibitor would make a great treatment for pain and inflammation. That is true. What’s surprising, or not, is that neither in the abstract nor in the full article are any of the useful NF-kB inhibitors found in nature mentioned. You would think the author would at least give a hat tip to some of the more common and more popular natural products that are known to inhibit NF-kB.

Ginger plus turmeric for wound healing

This study suggests that a combination of turmeric (curcumin) and ginger extract might provide a novel approach to improving structure and function in skin and, concomitantly, reducing formation of non-healing wounds.

Ginger may be helpful in the treatment of diabetes

Test tube experiments (“in vitro” means “in glass”) demonstrated that ginger components caused the release of additional insulin when that insulin release had been artificially blocked. In vivo (in life) experiments were then carried out on rats. These rat experiments confirmed the effect of ginger in a living mammal (though not a human.) Glucose levels decreased by 35% and insulin levels increased by 10%.

Anti-depressants for pain

In this study, mirtazapine (an anti-depressant) is found to inhibit NF-kB activation in the brain, thereby reducing inflammation and the mediators of inflammation in the brain.

Polyphenols reduce cancer risk by reducing inflammation

Even the federal government (USDA) recommends increasing your intake of fruits and vegetables, in part because a higher dietary intake, especially of dark green, deep yellow and other colorful fruits, will reduce your risk of cancer.

Chocolate milk for inflammation?

Flavonoids are believed to reduce inflammation. Chocolate rich in flavonoids. So, the theory goes, eating (or drinking) a substantial amount of chocolate could reduce inflammation. Does it work?

NF-kappaB

NF-kB disease associations

NF-kB is the Master Switch – the primary means by which inflammation is ‘adjusted’ – turned on and off. Many, many different molecules interact with NF-kB – some stimulating it (increasing inflammation) and others inhibiting it (decreasing inflammation.) The balance between these positive (pro-inflamatory) and negative (anti-inflammatory) influences determines the extent of inflammation at any given time.

Genetic defect leads to excess NF-kappaB activation in autoimmune conditions

NF-kB is the master regulator – the primary means by which inflammation is ‘adjusted’ – turned on and off. Many, many different molecules interact with NF-kB – some stimulating it (increasing inflammation) and others inhibiting it (decreasing inflammation.) The balance between these positive and negative forces determines the extent of inflammation at any given time.

Benlysta trial – analyzed

BENLYSTA inhibits the biological activity of B-lymphocyte stimulator, or BLyS. BLyS is a naturally occurring protein which is required for the survival and development of B-lymphocyte cells into mature plasma B cells.

Plasma B cells produce antibodies, the body’s first line of defense against infection. In lupus and certain other autoimmune diseases, elevated levels of BLyS are believed to contribute to the production of autoantibodies – antibodies that attack and destroy the body’s own healthy tissues. The results of prospective observational studies show a significant correlation of elevated levels of BLyS with SLE disease activity.